DVD Camcorders? Not Yet, Maybe Not Ever

DVD camcorders are getting a lot of attention, but I recommend against them for schools. iMovie, Windows Movie Maker, and most other video editors do not accept the format the DVDs record in, called MPEG-2. You’d need to convert it from MPEG2 to DV, a not-too-complicated process, but it can take time on less than brand-new computers, and it’s nowhere near as simple as importing DV (the format of MiniDV and Digital8) over Firewire. Plus, most only use small disks that have a limited recording time, it takes longer to “finalize” a disk so it’s viewable, and the cameras are much more expensive, starting at over $500 at Amazon.

(I’d also guess they’re more fragile, though I have no evidence; I base that guess on the relative fragility of portable CD players compared to camcorders and audio cassette players.)

For teachers or schools that need a new camera, I still recommend the MiniDV format, unless you have a library of Sony’s Digital8 or Hi8.

Within the next few years, before your new camera dies, there’s a real possibility that camcorders will move to direct-to-hard-disk storage (though Sony and others will be reluctant to give up the blank tape and disk business, so it may take longer than that). Best to leapfrog over what looks to be an interim technology.——-

Channel 101">Channel 101

The New York Times: “Time Belt” is one of the many satirical shows to make it on the lineup of Channel 101, a Web site whose programming team consists mainly of a no-mercy audience that meets monthly in Los Angeles. The brainchild of the writers Rob Schrab, 35, and Dan Harmon, 32, Channel 101 is part creative kaffeeklatsch, part group therapy for the showbiz-frustrated. It is meant to remove the obstacles and distractions of big-budget productions – agents, executives, ample catering budgets – yet retain a level of quality control.

The procedure is simple enough. Participants have to submit a five-minute digital video of their series, and if it is good enough, it battles it out at a monthly get-together at CineSpace, a West Hollywood bar and screening room. Each month, the audience votes on which five shows – both brand-new and returning – get to stay on the Channel 101 Web site. With audiences and prestige growing (Mr. Black and Drew Carey have made appearances on Channel 101 shows), a New York City spinoff, Channel 102, began earlier this year.

This is big – more opportunities for populist programming. Make sure you and your students consider this a viable option for creating and distributing their work.——-

Channel 101

With TV Fame Elusive, Video-Series Creators Seek Success Online
By BRIAN RAFTERY

Chris Tallman is not the kind of actor one could easily imagine as a swaggering, lady-killing television star. With a sensibly square haircut, khaki-clad fashion sense and a beer-built physique that betray his Milwaukee roots, Mr. Tallman seems more likely to play a love-starved sidekick than a leading man. Even one of his best friends says that the idea of Mr. Tallman landing his own high-adventure network show “would be against natural laws, for justifiable reasons.”

Yet last year, Mr. Tallman not only got a starring role – as the vengeful hero of a time-traveling sci-fi series, “Time Belt,” which lasted eight episodes – but also co-starred with Jack Black, and even got a few onscreen make-out sessions.

“Time Belt” is one of the many satirical shows to make it on the lineup of Channel 101, a Web site whose programming team consists mainly of a no-mercy audience that meets monthly in Los Angeles. The brainchild of the writers Rob Schrab, 35, and Dan Harmon, 32, Channel 101 is part creative kaffeeklatsch, part group therapy for the showbiz-frustrated. It is meant to remove the obstacles and distractions of big-budget productions – agents, executives, ample catering budgets – yet retain a level of quality control.

The procedure is simple enough. Participants have to submit a five-minute digital video of their series, and if it is good enough, it battles it out at a monthly get-together at CineSpace, a West Hollywood bar and screening room. Each month, the audience votes on which five shows – both brand-new and returning – get to stay on the Channel 101 Web site. With audiences and prestige growing (Mr. Black and Drew Carey have made appearances on Channel 101 shows), a New York City spinoff, Channel 102, began earlier this year.

The cable network FX once commissioned a Channel 101 pilot featuring Mr. Black, but it was never broadcast. Now, the only way to produce segments for Channel 101, or to watch them, is on its Web site, or at the monthly screening sessions.

“In order to get involved, you have no choice but to admit that the most important thing in the world for you is to entertain an audience,” Mr. Harmon said. “Because that’s all you’re going to get out of this.” That, and perhaps the chance to sit a few tables from Kato Kaelin.

The Channel 101 project was born of frustration. In 1999, Mr. Schrab and Mr. Harmon, friends from Milwaukee, wrote “Heat Vision and Jack,” a Fox pilot directed by Ben Stiller and starring Mr. Black as a motorcycle-riding genius. It was “The Six Million Dollar Man” meets “Knight Rider,” and though the pilot perfectly played up Mr. Black’s goofball likability years before “School of Rock,” Fox did not pick up the show. Its co-creators were devastated and hit a creative lull.

“We were damaged goods,” Mr. Schrab said. “We skyrocketed so quickly, we didn’t realize how lucky we were.” The duo pitched several similar shows but were repeatedly rejected. “Channel 101 is us recovering from that,” he said.

It is also an antidote to the terrifying pilot season happening in Hollywood, an annual pre-spring ritual that is a notoriously tense time. For actors, it is a time of awkward competition, as friends go up against friends for that potentially career-defining gig; for writers and producers, it is a soul-draining process of watching your beloved ideas shot down or stalled. “Stoplights and banana peels,” is Mr. Harmon’s description.

Mr. Schrab said the site receives an average of 30 submissions a month, and about 7 of them are put into competition. Several of the winning and losing short films are archived on the series’s Web site, www.channel101.com. Many entries follow similar themes: fake movie trailers are prevalent, as are pop-culture sendups that Mr. Harmon refers to as “Naughty Yankovics,” in which a beloved series is satirized in the extreme, like “Straight Eye for the Queer Guy.” Other submissions, Mr. Harmon said, are of the “Wayne’s World” variety, in which “there’s invariably a stuffed animal of some kind that’s really profane.”

What does make it past the judges are shows like “House of Cosbys,” an animated program featuring a household stuffed with Bill Cosby clones, or “The ‘Bu,” a sendup of “The O.C.” that occasionally features a boozy teenage puppet. But no show better summarizes the potential of Channel 101 than “Time Belt,” Mr. Tallman’s attempt at a Dr. Who-like fantasy series. With dinosaurs, Nazi babes and an 18th-century Parisian villain named Montague, “Time Belt” plays like a comic-book serial, and each episode ends with a cliffhanger. It is potentially campy, but Mr. Tallman, who wrote, directed and co-produced the show, took it very seriously.

“With Channel 101, you have to treat every episode as your last episode,” Mr. Tallman said from his home in Los Angeles, just a few hours before a pilot audition. “And for people who submit, a lot of times that’s a big mistake they make.”

“If you have any cool ideas,” he observed, “you put them in your first episode. And if you’re lucky enough to get picked up, then you have to come up with more cool ideas.”

“Time Belt” probably won’t be competing against ABC’s “Lost” anytime soon, but it has given Mr. Tallman more exposure and improved his confidence in his real-life acting gigs (he has a recurring role on Comedy Central’s “Reno 911”).

In fact, with the Los Angeles audiences swelling to nearly 300 attendees each month, Channel 101 has the potential to kick-start some careers. It is already responsible for helping Mr. Schrab and Mr. Harmon out of their post-”Heat Vision” funk. “Monster House,” an animated comedy they wrote and which is being produced by Robert Zemeckis and Steven Spielberg, is to be released next year.

The New York City-based Channel 102 does not have quite the following of its Los Angeles counterpart yet, but at its second gathering, held earlier this month on the Lower East Side, a group of about 100 revelers crowded into the back of the Parkside Lounge, voting on shows like “Jesus Christ Supercop,” “Locked in a Closet” and “Lightning Brains.”

The show had as its host a writer for VH1, Tony Carnevale. Mr. Carnevale, 28, had approached Mr. Harmon and Mr. Schrab last fall about an East Coast version of Channel 101, and drew on his friends from the comedy troupe the Upright Citizens Brigade to submit tapes (many of the faces on screen were in the crowd, and can be seen on the program’s site, www.channel102.net).

There have been no big names in attendance yet, which is fine by Mr. Carnevale, who wants the show to remain relatively low key for now. But he may not be able to keep it that way for long. The next event is scheduled for Monday night in the more spacious Upright Citizens Brigade Theater in Chelsea.

“I wanted to give New York a chance to develop its own style,” he said, adding, “I expect my role to be sort of thankless, and I’m O.K. with that because I didn’t come up with the idea, so I can’t expect fame and fortune.”

Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company——-

Tight Budget Lighting for Chroma Key">Tight Budget Lighting for Chroma Key

Keith Kolbo: “Lighting a large chroma key drop is not very difficult with a little attention to detail and a few good softboxes or studio multi-source instruments. Unfortunately I was fresh out of the couple of thousand dollars I would need for those lighting instruments. Once again I was on my way down to the local home improvement store to find a miracle. [...] The end result is excellent.”

A cheap, good, effective chroma lighting kit for what seems to be less than $200. Excellent.——-

DV Camera Dos and Don’ts

Dos:
Move smo-o-o-o-thly, no jerky movments

Vary your shots – low angle, high angle

Shoot from your subject’s eye level (especially with children)

Keep wide when taping action, so your subject doesn’t move out of the frame

Don’ts:

Don’t use LP mode; it’s a false economy, and the signal is unrecognized by most edit applications

Don’t set your sound to 12-bit or you’ll get audio drift in longer pieces; most edit apps only accept 16-bit

Don’t shoot with strong light behind your subject, unless you want silhouettes

Don’t ignore background sounds; they can obscure your subject’s voice
——-

Dean Rowe: DV Pass-Through in Windows Movie Maker 2.1">Dean Rowe: DV Pass-Through in Windows Movie Maker 2.1

Researching the Charlie White post below, I found Dean Rowe’s blog. Dean works with the Windows Movie Maker development team, and posts helpful tips as well as an occasional DirectShow technical explication.

Looking around there I found out that the DV Pass-Through feature now works – importing video into WMM2 using a DV camcorder or other analog/DV device on the fly without having to record on DV tape first. (And he posted this news in August of 2004…. Nice job, Tim, keeping up with the updates.) Dean points to a Microsoft DV pass-through tutorial.

If he’s right, WMM2 ought to capture from our JVC VHS/MiniDV combo VCR via analog-VHS-to-firewire-out. I’ll post when I can test it.——-

Charlie White: “Windows Movie Maker Makes It Easy”">Charlie White: “Windows Movie Maker Makes It Easy”

I’m doing a Windows Movie Maker workshop tomorrow morning, and looking through my blog drafts, came upon Charlie White’s introduction to WMM2. Charlie publishes all over DigitalMediaNet’s sites and publications, and this went online in January.

There are plenty of other WMM2 introductions around, and his is another good one.——-

Craft and Psychology">Craft and Psychology

Barry Braverman: How to ensure image integrity when encoding to DVD

“When it comes to outputting our finely crafted images to DVD, today’s shooter faces enormous opportunity and risk. Increasingly sophisticated tools like Apple DVD Studio Pro 3 and Compressor provide substantial capabilities in authoring and encoding, but only if we exploit these tools appropriately.”

Tips on optimizing in Apple’s DVD Studio Pro.——-

2005 iCademy Digital Film Festival">2005 iCademy Digital Film Festival

Barnaby Wasson of Arizona State wrote to me about their upcoming iCademy Digital Film Festival. I judged some of their entries a few years ago and saw some very good work. Consider entering some of your own or your students’ work.

Grab your camera and digital editing software to create a winning entry to the 2005 iCademy Digital Film Festival.

Submissions being accepted accepted til April 4th, 2005.

The iCademy Digital Film Festivalís mission is to encourage the creation of engaging instructional videos benefiting all students. The underlying aim, as always, is to generate greater interest in educational filmmaking.

There are fifteen categories divided into five separate age categories covering categories from Public Service Announcements, instructional videos, and digital stories, to educational best practices videos.

——-

Hidden Tricks in iDVD">Hidden Tricks in iDVD

Dave Nagel at DigitalMediaNet:

“We’ve covered iDVD’s hidden tricks over the last several versions, including the creation of custom buttons, custom highlights, duration changes for menus and more. Now, with version 5, there are several more areas available for customization, each one more complex than the last. But we’ll kick things off in the first installment in this series with a relatively simple process: creating your own custom DVD menu buttons and highlights.”——-